Peak Magic Johnson vs Peak Jokic

[Mask the Embiid]

I just want to see how stupid this website is.

[1987_Lakers]

Jokic

[Im Still Ballin]

This is a hard one. They played in two drastically different eras.

[FultzNationRISE]

Both great.

The premise there has to be a clear “order” is false.

It’s ok to just say it’s a pick em.


That said, I voted Jokic to spite OP.

[Carbine]

Their primes were 35 years apart. You can't compare.

[1987_Lakers]

I actually think Magic has one of the weaker peaks compared to the other top 10 greats. Arguably the GOAT playmaker, but his lack of scoring and defense compared to guys like MJ, LeBron, Wilt, Hakeem, Shaq, Kareem etc is pretty noticable. Bird also had a better peak than Magic.

[Mask the Embiid]

Both great.

The premise there has to be a clear “order” is false.

It’s ok to just say it’s a pick em.


That said, I voted Jokic to spite OP.

so you really think magic. got it.

[Mask the Embiid]

This is a hard one. They played in two drastically different eras.

No its not hard....either you think jokic is a top 4 player ever.......or u dont....its not a trick....its not a damn pick em......the answer is obvious and your going to expose your basketball iq with your vote....because magic is top 4...so if you have jokic over him...you have jokic over hakeem.....shaq.....bird......kobe..... wilt....bill russell....



expose yourselves low iqs! let everybody see you for what you are....you not gonna get to vote anonymously like the curry poll you cowards

[SouBeachTalents]

No its not hard....either you think jokic is a top 4 player ever.......or u dont....its not a trick....its not a damn pick em......the answer is obvious and your going to expose your basketball iq with your vote....because magic is top 4...so if you have jokic over him...you have jokic over hakeem.....shaq.....bird......kobe..... wilt....bill russell....



expose yourselves low iqs! let everybody see....you not gonna get to vote anonymously like the curry poll you cowards

You're asking about peak but bringing up all-time rank. This is some lazy ass trolling.

[Mask the Embiid]

You're asking about peak but bringing up all-time rank. This is some lazy ass trolling.

Why wont you vote? Cast your vote.....are you ashamed of your vote?

[SATAN]

Good thread, OP.

[Axe]

It's funny how you guys root for lebron but many of you don't actually get along with each other.

[SATAN]

It's funny how you guys root for lebron but many of you don't actually get along with each other.

LeBron fans a free thinkers. MJ stans are cult members.

[beasted]

Some people will call this an amateur evaluation, but the fact remains Magic became a household name at his peak. Soccer moms have no fukkin clue who Jokic is.

[TheMan]

Jokic by a hair peak wise but need for him to win another chip before definitely putting him over Magic who was leader of one of the GOAT dynasty teams who beat 2 out of 3 another legend during their rivalry.